Learning about Rosa (née Wertheimer) & Jakob Edelmuth

Update August 2019: The process of learning the story of Rosa (née Wertheimer) and Jakob Edelmuth did not end in 2015 as we thought. It continues. The article below outlines the story of how we learned about Rosa and Jacob more than it tells the story of their lives. Please see the Story of Rosa (née Wertheimer) and Jakob Edelmuth for a more straightforward account. Or contact Sharon Meen at s.meen79@gmail.com if you require clarification or have more information. Thank you.

opinion article examples https://tetratherapeutics.com/treatmentrx/rosuvastatin-crestor-40-mg-tablet-price/34/ https://lawdegree.com/questions/graduate-school-admissions-essay-sample/46/ get link assigning static ip https://moorelifeurgentcare.com/edtreatment/cost-viagra-walmart/84/ source site https://shepherdstown.info/conclusion/house-plant-expert-hessayon/17/ https://switzerlanddanceschool.com/case/a-dissertation-methodology/8/ frankenstein blade runner essay free example of an abstract for a term paper see url foreign policy essay dissertation quantitative data analysis how to write an intro to a college essay here united airlines seat assignment 2 essay in war woman world https://pinnacle.berea.edu/where/does-cialis-have-a-cumulative-effect/50/ essay publishing site allergy of viagra https://energy-analytics-institute.org/freefeatures/character-foil-essay-romeo-and-juliet/56/ https://www.psm.edu/package/fake-viagra-vs-real-viagra-inside-pill/89/ i can't write my essay pode beber e tomar levitra how to write a quantitative report https://pinnacle.berea.edu/where/atripla-with-cialis/50/ go here https://hudsonpubliclibrary.org/library/cornell-university-essay-prompt-2012/92/ https://doceremedspa.com/mgpills/cialis-mg-40/86/ https://workethic.org/order/levitra-prices-canada/85/ https://hhkidsdentist.com/advising/what-happens-when-you-mix-viagra-with-mr-clean/81/ *****

The laying of Stolpersteine for Rosa (née Wertheimer) and Jakob Edelmuth in Dessau on 20 March 2015 brings a form of closure to our search to assemble their story. It’s been a complicated and challenging task, and sadly we know most about the story of their lives under the Nazi Regime. Learning more about their lives before the Nazi Regime is a challenge we may not be able to meet.

We may, however, meet a different challenge: in our journey of discovery, we learned that Rosa Edelmuth, née Wertheimer, has more or less slipped out of the narrative of either her family, the Wertheimers of Marisfeld, Themar and Coburg, and of the Edelmuths of Beuern. We hope that telling what we do know may in some measure honour their memory and restore them to their family circles.

*****

Rosa Wertheimer, 1938 - SaraWe met Rosa Edelmuth, née Wertheimer, in 2009 — right at the beginning of the “Themar Lost & Found Project” — with several documents in the Themar City Archives. The first was Rosa’s letter of 31 December 1938 to the Themar Standesamt/Registry. It confirmed the addition of the name ‘Sara’ to her given names, in compliance with the law of August 1938 requiring all Jews to do so. [Men were required to add the name ‘Israel’.] The letter told us her names — birth and married — her birthdate, and the address at which she was then living — Franzstr. 3-4/II in Dessau in the province of Anhalt.

Rosa Sara Edelmuth, 1938-3A letter dated 12 April 1939 and its envelope provided more snippets. Themar’s City Administrator responded to Rosa’s request for a certificate of citizenship. He told her to complete and submit a form, and return it with supporting documentation and information about her husband; he promised to return the documents.

Rosa Edelmuth, 1939 (2)The letter did not reach Rosa and was returned to Themar on 14 April 1939. On the back of the envelope, written in pencil, were the words “verzogen nach Holland-13/4/- moved to Holland.13.April.” At the bottom was the note of the Themar administrator:

W. Z. (?), 20/4./39.
“Das Schreiben mit Fragebogen ist heute an Markus Rosenberg ausgehändigt worden.
Die Schwester der Rosa Sara Edelmuth, geb. Wertheimer (Ehefrau des Milton Wertheimer in Berlin) kommt nächste Woche nach Themar. Diese soll bei ihrer Schwester in Holland anfragen, ob sie den Staatsangehörigkeitsausweis noch benötigt.”
“The letter with a questionnaire was given to Markus Rosenberg today.
The sister of Rosa Sara Edelmuth, b. Wertheimer (wife of Milton Wertheimer in Berlin) will come to Themar next week. She will ask her sister in Holland if she still needs the citizenship card.”

Rosa Edelmuth-20.4.1939-2

The first search of the German National Archives Gedenkbuch/Memorial Book and Yad Vashem online records informed us that Rosa had not found safe haven in Holland or elsewhere in the world. She had been deported from Holland in 1943, first to Theresienstadt Ghetto, and then on to Auschwitz.

S. Wolf, entry for Rosa’s sister, Bella.

These records did not tell us the name of Rosa’s husband: Gedenkbuch entries do not establish marital ties and no one had submitted a Page of Testimony to Yad Vashem for Rosa that might have done this. The remarkable database compiled by Siegfried Wolf and colleagues, Juden in Thüringen: biographischen Daten 1933-1945 contained info about Milton Wertheimer and Bella Wertheimer (née Wertheimer) but did not include a separate entry for Rosa, only identifying her as the sister/Schwester of Bella Wertheimer.

And so the matter rested and we turned to other research and learned more about Rosa’s siblings, Julius and Bella. Julius Wertheimer and his family had been able to leave Germany in 1936 and we followed their trail through the 1936 ship’s manifest, census documents in the States, and the discovery that Julius’s son, Alfred, had shot to fame for his stunning 1956 photos of Elvis Presley. We learned that Bella had married a Wertheimer cousin, Milton, also born in Themar, and her name was therefore Bella Wertheimer, née Wertheimer.

Then, in January 2011, Dr. Bernd Ulbrich from Dessau contacted us about members of several of Themar’s Jewish families who had lived in Dessau and provided the critical information about Rosa’s husband, Jakob Edelmuth. The 2008 brochure, STOLPERSTEINE für Dessau-Roßlau Ein Beitrag zur lokalen Gedenkkultur, contained this entry:

Haus Franzstrasse 3-4Jakob Edelmuth 1884–?
Rosa Edelmuth geb. Wertheimer 1887–1944

Im Haus Franzstraße 3–4 lebte auch das Kaufmannsehepaar Jakob und Rosa Edelmuth. Jakob Edelmuth stammte aus Beuren in Hessen, seine Frau Rosa war in Themar im Kreis Hildburghausen geboren worden. Unmittelbar nach der traumatischen Erfahrung des Novemberpogroms beschlossen die Edelmuths, Dessau zu verlassen und nach den Niederlanden zu emigrieren. […]Im Mai 1940 wurden die Niederlande von der deutschen Wehrmacht besetzt und die in den Niederlanden lebenden Juden gerieten in die Mühlen der NS-Judenpolitik. Rosa Edelmuth wurde am 22.4.1943 nach Theresienstadt, von dort am 6.9.1943 nach Auschwitz deportiert. Sie wurde 1944 in Auschwitz ermordet. Von ihrem Mann Jakob weiß man nur, dass er vermutlich schon 1942 in eines der Ghettos oder Vernichtungslager in Polen deportiert wurde.”
The married couple of Jakob and Rosa Edelmuth also lived at Haus Franzstraße 3–4. Jakob Edelmuth came from Beuren in Hesse, his wife Rosa had been born in Themar in Hildburghausen. Immediately after the traumatic experience of the November pogrom, the Edelmuths decided to leave Dessau and emigrate to the Netherlands. […] In May 1940, the Netherlands were occupied by the German Wehrmacht and the Jews living in the Netherlands fell into the mills of the NS Jewish policy. Rosa Edelmuth was deported to Theresienstadt on 22.4.1943, from there on 6.9.1943 to Auschwitz. She was murdered in Auschwitz in 1944. Of her husband Jakob we only know that he was probably deported to one of the ghettos or extermination camps in Poland in 1942. ”

1936 AB Dessau

1936 Dessau Adressbuch

Then, in 2013, one of Julius Wertheimer’s granddaughter contacted us as she was planning a trip to her father’s hometown of Coburg:: “Finding the website,” she wrote,” has been an amazing piece to a puzzle that I have been trying to piece together for a long time. I did not know that my grandfather had siblings who died in concentration camps, let alone that my grandfather had siblings.” Later that year, she visited Marisfeld, Themar and Coburg, where she collected important documents for us from the City Archives. These told us, for example, of the connections between those Wertheimers in Coburg and Rosa and Jakob Edelmuth in Dessau. For example, Nathan Wertheimer moved to Dessau in 1934 to live with Rosa and Jakob. Milton Wertheimer, Bella’s husband, stayed several times with his in-laws, Rosa and Jakob, through the 1930s.

GB-Rosa WBy 2014/15, updates to the online Gedenkbuch and the development of the Joods Memorial detailed succinctly the fate of the Edelmuths: on 21 February 1939, they left Dessau for Holland. They lived in Rotterdam at Blaakstraat 11/III.

GB-JW

Unfortunately, emigration to Holland did not provide safety. The invasion of the Netherlands in May 1940 had more or less trapped them even though the first years of Nazi occupation were somewhat bearable. But
on 15 July 1942, the deportations from the transit camp of Westerbork began and the trains went direct to Auschwitz. On 3 October 1942, Rosa and Jacob Edelmuth were rounded up in Rotterdam and taken to the transit camp of Westerbork where they remained imprisoned for six months.

On 21 April 1943, they were on the first transport from Amsterdam to Theresienstadt Ghetto. According to the deportation chronology on the Gedenkbuch site, this transport “consisted exclusively of German Jews, of whom 195 were taken from Westerbork.” Among them were World War I soldiers who had been decorated or wounded; they were told that Theresienstadt was a retirement home for privileged Jews. Also on the transport was Milton Wertheimer, husband of Rosa’s sister Bella, who had also been living in Holland (Amsterdam) since 1936. Rosa and Jakob were in Theresienstadt Ghetto six months before being transported further to Auschwitz. Both were murdered on 9 March 1943.

*****

But, while the outline of their story became clearer, puzzles remain: in particular, Rosa seems lost to the story of both the Wertheimer and Edelmuth families.

Foto: G. Schuller

Photo: Gaby Schuller, Coburg, 2019

First, Rosa’s presence in Coburg left little or no trace. The Wertheimer family moved from Themar to Coburg in the 1900s — exactly when we do not know — and Rosa probably lived there before her marriage. Her parents, Nathan and Malwine, and siblings Julius and Bella remained in Coburg. Malwine died in 1926; In 1934, Nathan Wertheimer moved from Coburg to Dessau to live with Rosa and Jakob. In 1936, Julius and his family left Germany for the United States. Bella remained in Coburg working at the Jewish boarding school; this ended in the Reichspogromnacht when the school was demolished. Bella left Coburg in early 1934 but remained in Thüringen until 1942 when she was rounded up in Meiningen and deported to Belzyce Ghetto.

After the war, when someone (family members and Coburg residents in 2013 do not know who) sponsored a gravestone for Malwine Wertheimer, it recorded only the names of her daughter and son-in-law, Bella and Milton Wertheimer.

Rosa was also not to be found within available sources of the Edelmuth family. Initially it seemed possible that Rosa was Jakob’s second wife after the death of his first wife, Minna Kadden in 1912. But no further evidence of this link was found; moreover, there is confusion about who Jakob’s parents and siblings were, and the fact that there were two Jakob Edelmuths of Beuern, one born in 1884 and one in 1885.

****

Yet we have continued to learn more about the Edelmuths. First, we traced Rosa’s family roots — the Wertheimers and Frankenbergs — back into the 1700s in Marisfeld, Sachsen-Meiningen/Thüringen. See:
Descendants List: Nathan (Jonas) & Regine (née Neuberger) Frankenberg
The Wertheimer Family of Marisfeld and Themar

Second, we learned about Jakob Edelmuth’s family thanks to the research of Hanno Müller and the 2013 publication of his book, Juden im Busecker Tal. Teil 1: Familien (2013) and to primary documents available on the internet.

As the birth certificate at left documents, Jacob Edelmuth was born on 14 January 1884 in Beuern in Hessen. He was the son of Süßmann and Hannche (née Edelmuth) Edelmuth. Jacob was a twin, and he and twin brother Hugo were the youngest children. Their births came after Süßmann and Hannche had lost two children — Gustav, b. 1881, and Johanna, b. 1882 — in infancy. Jacob and Hugo were therefore significantly younger than their siblings Lina, Berthold, and Kathinka.

Once we knew who Jacob’s parents and siblings were, we were able to follow the stories of his family and provide him with some familial context. Pages of Testimony submitted to Yad Vashem identified places where the Edelmuths lived — for example, Mellrichstadt, where Hugo lived with his family; and the stories that have accompanied the laying of Stolpersteine for Edelmuth family members all contributed.

124

This PoT tells us that Johannete Mariane Edelmuth was known as Hannche to her family.

As with Rosa’s family, only one member of the family Süßmann and Hannche Edelmuth who were alive in 1933, escaped. Ilse Krebs, née Edelmuth, the daughter of Jakob’s eldest sister, Lina, was able to leave Germany. In late summer 1938, she left for America with her husband Friedrich/Fritz Krebs and their 17-year-old son, Irwin. The 1940 Federal Census recorded them living in Baltimore but they subsequently moved to Rochester, where Fritz died in 1981. After the war, Ilse Krebs submitted Pages of Testimony to Yad Vashem.

In 2018, we received some unexpected news: Rosa and Jakob Edelmuth had two children: a daughter, Lieselotte, b. 1913 in Halle/Saale and son, Siegbert, b. 1917 in Coburg. Both survived the Holocaust and World War II.

One further detail emerged with the online publication of records in the Bad Arolsen Archives in 2019. Records for Jacob Edelmuth confirmed that he had been arrested in the Reichspogromnacht of 9/10 November 1938 and imprisoned in Buchenwald. He was released on 6 December 1938. The entry in the German National Archives, Memorial Book, which would normally have this fact in its entry, has not yet included it.

We certainly know more now about Rosa Wertheimer and her husband Jacob Edelmuth than we did in 2009, but should anyone reading this page have information, questions or comments, please contact Sharon Meen at s.meen79@gmail.com or smeen@mail.ubc.ca. We look forward to hearing from you.

*****

Below is a Descendants List for Süssmann and Johannette Edelmuth as identified by H. Müller and supplemented by other sources cited at the bottom.

  • Süßmann EDELMUTH, b. 08 Aug 1850, d. 18 Jun 1912
  • ∞ (23 Feb 1875) Hannchen (Johannette Mariane) EDELMUTH, b. 27 Feb 1851 Reiskirchen, d. 15 Jul 1891 Gießen
  • 1. Lina EDELMUTH, b. 29 Dec 1875 Beuern, d. 08 Nov 1940 Gießen
  • Löb Levy WETZSTEIN, b. 15 Sep 1872 Treis, murdered 26 Jan 1943 Theresienstadt
  • 2. Ilse WETZSTEIN, b. abt 1900 Treis, 1938/USA
  • ∞ Friedrich/Fritz KREBS, b. 14 Oct 1896 Berleburg, 1938/USA, d. 21 Jan 1981 Rochester/NY
  • 3. Irwin KREBS, b. abt 1923 Treis, 1938/USA
  • 3. Benno KREBS, b. 05 Sep 1925 Treis, d. 11 Feb 1931 Treis
  • 2. Berthold EDELMUTH, b. 19 Dec 1877 Beuern, d. 28 Jan 1913 Gießen
  • ∞ Bertha LILIENSTEIN, b. 21 Dec 1880 Goßfelden, Sep 1942 deported to Trebllnka, murdered
  • 3. Leopold EDELMUTH, b. 01 Jul 1907 Gießen, Sep 1942 deported to Trebllnka, murdered.
  • 3. Irma EDELMUTH, b. 14 Jun 1911 Gießen, Sep 1942 deported to Trebllnka, murdered.
  • 1. Kathinka EDELMUTH, b. 17 Nov 1879 Beuern, Sep 1942 deported to Trebllnka, murdered.
  • ∞ Jakob HESS
  • 1. Gustav EDELMUTH, b. 20 Dec 1881 Beuern, d. 22 Dec 1881 Beuern
  • 1, Johanna EDELMUTH, b. 19 Nov 1882 Beuern, d. 17 Jan 1883 Beuern
  • 1. Hugo EDELMUTH, b. 14 Jan 1884 Beuern, April 1942 deported to Krasnystaw, murdered
  • Adele OTTENSOSER, b. 11 Jul 1884 Mellrichstadt, April 1942 deported to Krasnystaw, murdered
  • 2. Siegfried EDELMUTH, b. 22 Sep 1912 Mellrichstadt, murdered 23 Jul 1941 Mathausen-Gusen
  • 2. Ilse EDELMUTH, b.18 Jan 1923 Mellrichstadt, April 1942 deported to Krasnystaw, murdered
  • 1. Jacob EDELMUTH, b. 14 Jan 1884 Beuern, 1939 to Holland, murdered 09 Mar 1944 Auschwitz
  • Rosa WERTHEIMER, b. 7 Jun 1887 Themar, 1939 to Holland, murdered 9 Mar 1944 Auschwitz
  • 2. Lieselotte EDELMUTH, b 15 Sep 1913 Halle/Saale, 1933 to Holland, 1952 to South Africa, d. abt 1986 Frankfurt a/Main
  • ∞ (1933) Edwin Georg Sigfried Karl MEDER, b. 24 May 1906 Frankfurt/Main, 1952 to South Africa, d. abt 1983 South Africa
  • 2. Siegbert EDELMUTH, b. 4 Aug 1917 Coburg, [c. 1935] to South Africa, d. 03 Sep 1981 Johannesburg/SA

*****

Acknowledgments:
We wish to thank:
1. Bernd Ulbrich of Dessau for his contributions to our knowledge of the Edelmuth family in Dessau.
2. Mr. Hanno Müller of Giessen for his information about Jakob Edelmuth’s family. His website is http://www.fambu-oberhessen.de. In particular, Mr. Müller clarified the distinction between the two Jakob Edelmuths were born in Beuern, one in 1884 and the other in 1885. For more information on Rosa’s husband, and the familial context please see this page.

Sources:
Ancestry.com. U.S. City Directories, 1822-1989 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2011.
Ancestry.com. Florida Death Index, 1877-1998 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2004.
Ancestry.com Hessisches Hauptstaatsarchiv; Wiesbaden, Deutschland; bestand: 905; Laufende Nummer: 159)
Arolsen Online Archive
Das Bundesarchiv. Gedenkbuch.
Das Holocaust Erinnerungsmal in Bad Nauheim, Löb Wetzstein
,,Elf Stolpersteine in Buseck wider das Vergessen.”
Giessener Allgemeine, 17.02.2014
Phil Bicker, “Elvis in the Beginning: Photographs by Alfred Wertheimer.Time Magazine,05 March 1913.
National Archives and Records Administration (NARA); Washington, D.C.; Indexes to Naturalization petitions to the U.S. Circuit and District Courts for Maryland, 1797-1951; Microfilm Serial: M1168; Microfilm Roll: 21
The National Archives at St. Louis; St. Louis, Missouri; World War II Draft Cards (Fourth Registration) for the State of Maryland; State Headquarters: Maryland; Microfilm Series: M1939; Microfilm Roll: 33
Werkstatt Gedenkkultur. STOLPERSTEINE für Dessau-Roßlau Ein Beitrag zur lokalen Gedenkkultur. Dessau, 2008.
Treis an der Lumda, Hauptstraße 85 Stolperstein für Löb Wetzstein
Wir wollen uns erinnern (Würzburg)
Yad Vashem. Würzburg during the Holocaust, 25 April 1942 — The Third Deportation from Würzburg.
Year: 1938; Arrival: New York, New York; Microfilm Serial: T715, 1897-1957; Microfilm Roll: Roll 6204; Line: 11; Page Number: 62
Year: 1940; Census Place: Baltimore, Baltimore City, Maryland; Roll: T627_1522; Page: 9A; Enumeration District: 4-369